{"corpus_id":20097948,"paper_sha":"12d42f4f404fb1fde3dd85aa4358562a004c68a9","doi":"10.1146/ANNUREV.ENTO.51.110104.151124","arxiv_id":null,"pmid":16332221,"pmcid":null,"mag_id":2169484028,"dblp_id":null,"acl_id":null,"title":"Developments in aquatic insect biomonitoring: a comparative analysis of recent approaches.","year":2006,"publication_date":null,"venue":"Annual Review of Entomology","journal":{"name":"Annual review of entomology","pages":"\n          495-523\n        ","volume":"51"},"journal_issn":null,"journal_title":null,"publication_types":["JournalArticle","Study","Review"],"pubmed_pub_types":["Comparative Study","Journal Article","Research Support, Non-U.S. Gov't"],"s2_fields_of_study":["Biology","Medicine","Environmental Science"],"reference_count":149,"citation_count":961,"influential_citation_count":43,"is_open_access":false,"arxiv_categories":null,"arxiv_license":null,"arxiv_journal_ref":null,"mesh_headings":[{"d":"Animals","mj":false,"ui":"D000818"},{"d":"Biological Assay","mj":false,"ui":"D001681"},{"d":"Biomarkers","mj":false,"ui":"D015415"},{"d":"Ecosystem","mj":true,"ui":"D017753"},{"d":"Environmental Monitoring","mj":false,"qs":[{"q":"methods","mj":true,"ui":"Q000379"}],"ui":"D004784"},{"d":"Food","mj":false,"qs":[{"q":"classification","mj":false,"ui":"Q000145"}],"ui":"D005502"},{"d":"Geologic Sediments","mj":false,"qs":[{"q":"analysis","mj":false,"ui":"Q000032"}],"ui":"D019015"},{"d":"Insecta","mj":false,"qs":[{"q":"physiology","mj":true,"ui":"Q000502"}],"ui":"D007313"},{"d":"Invertebrates","mj":false,"ui":"D007448"},{"d":"Plant Leaves","mj":false,"ui":"D018515"},{"d":"Water","mj":false,"ui":"D014867"}],"chemicals":[{"n":"Biomarkers","ui":"D015415","reg":"0"},{"n":"Water","ui":"D014867","reg":"059QF0KO0R"}],"comments_corrections":null,"source_flags":5,"s2_open_access_pdf_url":null,"s2_open_access_landing_url":null,"s2_open_access_license":null,"s2_open_access_status":null,"pmc_open_access_pdf_url":null,"pmc_open_access_landing_url":null,"pmc_open_access_license":null,"pmc_open_access_status":null,"unpaywall_open_access_pdf_url":null,"unpaywall_open_access_landing_url":null,"unpaywall_open_access_license":null,"unpaywall_open_access_status":null,"abstract":"Aquatic insects and other benthic invertebrates are the most widely used organisms in freshwater biomonitoring of human impact. Because of the high monetary investment in freshwater management, decisions are often based on biomonitoring results, and a critical and comparative review of different approaches is required. We used 12 criteria that should be fulfilled by an \"ideal\" biomonitoring tool, addressing the rationale, implementation, and performance of a method. After illustrating how the century-old but still widely used Saprobian system does not meet these criteria, we apply them to nine recent approaches that range from the suborganismal to the ecosystem level. Although significant progress has been made in the field, no recent approach meets all 12 criteria. Given that the use of biomonitoring information has important financial consequences, we suggest that societies and governments prioritize how these criteria should be ranked.","claims":[{"public_id":"cl_aa24f5e676aa268e60be8825a063dc2b","status":"active","text":"Nine recent approaches to aquatic insect biomonitoring were assessed across levels ranging from the suborganismal level to the ecosystem level.","confidence":0.9,"contributors":[{"id":35,"public_id":"b2adb6bfad","public_label":"Anonymous (b2adb6bfad)","roles":["extraction"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/b2adb6bfad"},{"id":1165,"public_id":"ezd9qvkvax","public_label":"The Reverser‮ (ezd9qvkvax)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/ezd9qvkvax"},{"id":17,"public_id":"322360f1c1","public_label":"Killer Whale (322360f1c1)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/322360f1c1"}],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/claims/cl_aa24f5e676aa268e60be8825a063dc2b"},{"public_id":"cl_a2ae3cf5aca5b8ef6efbb6f336113924","status":"active","text":"No recent approach evaluated meets all 12 criteria, despite significant progress in aquatic insect biomonitoring.","confidence":0.94,"contributors":[{"id":35,"public_id":"b2adb6bfad","public_label":"Anonymous (b2adb6bfad)","roles":["extraction"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/b2adb6bfad"},{"id":1165,"public_id":"ezd9qvkvax","public_label":"The Reverser‮ (ezd9qvkvax)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/ezd9qvkvax"},{"id":17,"public_id":"322360f1c1","public_label":"Killer Whale (322360f1c1)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/322360f1c1"}],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/claims/cl_a2ae3cf5aca5b8ef6efbb6f336113924"},{"public_id":"cl_e098a189db63fac8b67624e9c7a3036d","status":"active","text":"The Saprobian system does not meet the 12 criteria used to characterize an ideal biomonitoring tool.","confidence":0.93,"contributors":[{"id":35,"public_id":"b2adb6bfad","public_label":"Anonymous (b2adb6bfad)","roles":["extraction"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/b2adb6bfad"},{"id":1165,"public_id":"ezd9qvkvax","public_label":"The Reverser‮ (ezd9qvkvax)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/ezd9qvkvax"},{"id":17,"public_id":"322360f1c1","public_label":"Killer Whale (322360f1c1)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/322360f1c1"}],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/claims/cl_e098a189db63fac8b67624e9c7a3036d"}],"concepts":[{"public_id":"co_0711c00610d44f983b5727a9b3ad1234","status":"active","name":"ecosystem level","description":"A broad ecological scale included among the compared biomonitoring approaches.","types":["biological scale"],"aliases":[],"contributors":[{"id":35,"public_id":"b2adb6bfad","public_label":"Anonymous (b2adb6bfad)","roles":["extraction"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/b2adb6bfad"},{"id":1165,"public_id":"ezd9qvkvax","public_label":"The Reverser‮ (ezd9qvkvax)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/ezd9qvkvax"},{"id":17,"public_id":"322360f1c1","public_label":"Killer Whale (322360f1c1)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/322360f1c1"}],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/concepts/co_0711c00610d44f983b5727a9b3ad1234"},{"public_id":"co_1114ff176c5b88ffd31d52825414c947","status":"active","name":"nine recent approaches","description":"The contemporary biomonitoring approaches compared against the stated criteria.","types":["method set"],"aliases":[],"contributors":[{"id":35,"public_id":"b2adb6bfad","public_label":"Anonymous (b2adb6bfad)","roles":["extraction"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/b2adb6bfad"},{"id":1165,"public_id":"ezd9qvkvax","public_label":"The Reverser‮ (ezd9qvkvax)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/ezd9qvkvax"},{"id":17,"public_id":"322360f1c1","public_label":"Killer Whale (322360f1c1)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/322360f1c1"}],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/concepts/co_1114ff176c5b88ffd31d52825414c947"},{"public_id":"co_1413ea27ca3eba633c13a05182784a97","status":"active","name":"Saprobian system","description":"A long-used freshwater biomonitoring system evaluated against the stated criteria.","types":["biomonitoring system"],"aliases":[],"contributors":[{"id":35,"public_id":"b2adb6bfad","public_label":"Anonymous (b2adb6bfad)","roles":["extraction"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/b2adb6bfad"},{"id":1165,"public_id":"ezd9qvkvax","public_label":"The Reverser‮ (ezd9qvkvax)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/ezd9qvkvax"},{"id":17,"public_id":"322360f1c1","public_label":"Killer Whale (322360f1c1)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/322360f1c1"}],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/concepts/co_1413ea27ca3eba633c13a05182784a97"},{"public_id":"co_63faee94baacaebd402302f52a0c9758","status":"active","name":"benthic invertebrates","description":"Bottom-dwelling invertebrate organisms used in freshwater biomonitoring.","types":["organism group"],"aliases":[],"contributors":[{"id":35,"public_id":"b2adb6bfad","public_label":"Anonymous (b2adb6bfad)","roles":["extraction"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/b2adb6bfad"},{"id":1165,"public_id":"ezd9qvkvax","public_label":"The Reverser‮ (ezd9qvkvax)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/ezd9qvkvax"},{"id":17,"public_id":"322360f1c1","public_label":"Killer Whale (322360f1c1)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/322360f1c1"}],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/concepts/co_63faee94baacaebd402302f52a0c9758"},{"public_id":"co_84a92ea303aa02eb56cfc9e48d378f7b","status":"active","name":"12 criteria","description":"A set of evaluation criteria addressing the rationale, implementation, and performance of biomonitoring methods.","types":["evaluation framework"],"aliases":[],"contributors":[{"id":35,"public_id":"b2adb6bfad","public_label":"Anonymous (b2adb6bfad)","roles":["extraction"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/b2adb6bfad"},{"id":1165,"public_id":"ezd9qvkvax","public_label":"The Reverser‮ (ezd9qvkvax)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/ezd9qvkvax"},{"id":17,"public_id":"322360f1c1","public_label":"Killer Whale (322360f1c1)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/322360f1c1"}],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/concepts/co_84a92ea303aa02eb56cfc9e48d378f7b"},{"public_id":"co_9312d921f73dfee53e43bff74ac2f1a1","status":"active","name":"freshwater biomonitoring","description":"The use of organisms or biological responses to assess human impact in freshwater systems.","types":["assessment method"],"aliases":[],"contributors":[{"id":35,"public_id":"b2adb6bfad","public_label":"Anonymous (b2adb6bfad)","roles":["extraction"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/b2adb6bfad"},{"id":1165,"public_id":"ezd9qvkvax","public_label":"The Reverser‮ (ezd9qvkvax)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/ezd9qvkvax"},{"id":17,"public_id":"322360f1c1","public_label":"Killer Whale (322360f1c1)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/322360f1c1"}],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/concepts/co_9312d921f73dfee53e43bff74ac2f1a1"},{"public_id":"co_a09733898fc030fc9f298a37398b864a","status":"active","name":"aquatic insect biomonitoring","description":"Biomonitoring focused on aquatic insects as indicators in freshwater assessment.","types":["assessment approach"],"aliases":[],"contributors":[{"id":35,"public_id":"b2adb6bfad","public_label":"Anonymous (b2adb6bfad)","roles":["extraction"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/b2adb6bfad"},{"id":1165,"public_id":"ezd9qvkvax","public_label":"The Reverser‮ (ezd9qvkvax)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/ezd9qvkvax"},{"id":17,"public_id":"322360f1c1","public_label":"Killer Whale (322360f1c1)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/322360f1c1"}],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/concepts/co_a09733898fc030fc9f298a37398b864a"},{"public_id":"co_b6759296bce38efa83fbbf6e7446880e","status":"active","name":"aquatic insects","description":"Insects living in freshwater environments that are used as organisms for biomonitoring human impact.","types":["organism group"],"aliases":[],"contributors":[{"id":35,"public_id":"b2adb6bfad","public_label":"Anonymous (b2adb6bfad)","roles":["extraction"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/b2adb6bfad"},{"id":1165,"public_id":"ezd9qvkvax","public_label":"The Reverser‮ (ezd9qvkvax)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/ezd9qvkvax"},{"id":17,"public_id":"322360f1c1","public_label":"Killer Whale (322360f1c1)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/322360f1c1"}],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/concepts/co_b6759296bce38efa83fbbf6e7446880e"},{"public_id":"co_bb7374e51106b3c1a87c94099bd14103","status":"active","name":"suborganismal level","description":"A biological scale below the whole-organism level included among the compared approaches.","types":["biological scale"],"aliases":[],"contributors":[{"id":35,"public_id":"b2adb6bfad","public_label":"Anonymous (b2adb6bfad)","roles":["extraction"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/b2adb6bfad"},{"id":1165,"public_id":"ezd9qvkvax","public_label":"The Reverser‮ (ezd9qvkvax)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/ezd9qvkvax"},{"id":17,"public_id":"322360f1c1","public_label":"Killer Whale (322360f1c1)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/322360f1c1"}],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/concepts/co_bb7374e51106b3c1a87c94099bd14103"},{"public_id":"co_beeeaab50bf1c8443d83c10ddc168375","status":"active","name":"ideal biomonitoring tool","description":"A benchmark biomonitoring method expected to satisfy the stated evaluation criteria.","types":["benchmark concept"],"aliases":[],"contributors":[{"id":35,"public_id":"b2adb6bfad","public_label":"Anonymous (b2adb6bfad)","roles":["extraction"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/b2adb6bfad"},{"id":1165,"public_id":"ezd9qvkvax","public_label":"The Reverser‮ (ezd9qvkvax)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/ezd9qvkvax"},{"id":17,"public_id":"322360f1c1","public_label":"Killer Whale (322360f1c1)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/322360f1c1"}],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/concepts/co_beeeaab50bf1c8443d83c10ddc168375"},{"public_id":"co_ef9237c32b99d0c584dc3e9d492e59f0","status":"active","name":"human impact","description":"Anthropogenic effects on freshwater environments that biomonitoring methods are intended to assess.","types":["environmental pressure"],"aliases":[],"contributors":[{"id":35,"public_id":"b2adb6bfad","public_label":"Anonymous (b2adb6bfad)","roles":["extraction"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/b2adb6bfad"},{"id":1165,"public_id":"ezd9qvkvax","public_label":"The Reverser‮ (ezd9qvkvax)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/ezd9qvkvax"},{"id":17,"public_id":"322360f1c1","public_label":"Killer Whale (322360f1c1)","roles":["review"],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/u/322360f1c1"}],"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/concepts/co_ef9237c32b99d0c584dc3e9d492e59f0"}],"external_ids":{"DOI":"10.1146/ANNUREV.ENTO.51.110104.151124","ArXiv":null,"PubMed":16332221,"PubMedCentral":null,"MAG":2169484028,"DBLP":null,"ACL":null},"open_access":{"is_open_access":false,"pdf_url":null,"landing_url":"https://sah.borca.ai/papers/20097948","source":null,"pdf_url_source":null,"license":null,"reason":"pdf_url_not_indexed"},"reference_availability":{"status":"available","references_indexed":true,"full_text_available":false,"full_text_source":null,"count_basis":"semantic_scholar_metadata","extraction_status":"not_applicable","reason":null},"source":{"provider":"episteme2","base_corpus":"semantic_scholar_dump","freshness_mode":"unknown","basis":["semantic_scholar_metadata","postgres_metadata"],"limits":["paper metadata is based on indexed upstream scholarly datasets","claims and concepts are available only for extracted papers","absence of claims or concepts means no extracted graph data is available in this response"],"status":"available","degraded":false,"degraded_reasons":[],"diagnostics":{"status":"available","degraded":false,"degraded_reasons":[],"metadata_status":"available","graph_status":"available","abstract_status":"available"},"source_flags":5},"paper_id":632344,"paper_uid":"08fd8270-6dfd-436c-acb5-7699881ab5ab","canonical_identity":{"paper_id":632344,"paper_uid":"08fd8270-6dfd-436c-acb5-7699881ab5ab","identity_status":"available","lookup_basis":"semantic_scholar_external_id","compatibility_path":"corpus_id"},"url":"https://sah.borca.ai/papers/20097948"}