Surface soil moisture retrievals from remote sensing: Current status, products & future trends

G. Petropoulos,G. Ireland,B. Barrett

Published 2015 in Physics and Chemistry of The Earth

ABSTRACT

No abstract is available for this paper.

PUBLICATION RECORD

Publication year
2015
Venue
Physics and Chemistry of The Earth
Publication date
Unknown publication date
Fields of study
Computer Science, Environmental Science
Identifiers
DOI 10.1016/J.PCE.2015.02.009
External record
Open on Semantic Scholar
Source metadata
Semantic Scholar

CITATION MAP

EXTRACTION MAP

CLAIMS

No claims are published for this paper.

CONCEPTS

No concepts are published for this paper.

REFERENCES

A Preliminary Study toward Consistent Soil Moisture from AMSR2
2015cited by this paper
Evaluation of the ESA CCI soil moisture product using ground-based observations
2015cited by this paper
Validating the Modified Perpendicular Drought Index in the North China Region Using In Situ Soil Moisture Measurement
2015cited by this paper
Surface Soil Water Content Estimation from Thermal Remote Sensing based on the Temporal Variation of Land Surface Temperature
2014cited by this paper
The Soil Moisture Active Passive Experiments (SMAPEx): Toward Soil Moisture Retrieval From the SMAP Mission
2014cited by this paper
The scale-dependence of SMOS soil moisture accuracy and its improvement through land data assimilation in the central Tibetan Plateau
2014cited by this paper
Influence of Radar Frequency on the Relationship Between Bare Surface Soil Moisture Vertical Profile and Radar Backscatter
2014cited by this paper
Analysis on Soil Moisture Estimation of SAR Data Based on Coherent Scattering Model
2014cited by this paper
Improving soil moisture retrievals from a physically-based radiative transfer model
2014cited by this paper
On the spatio-temporal dynamics of soil moisture at the field scale
2014cited by this paper
Validation of the ASCAT Soil Water Index using in situ data from the International Soil Moisture Network
2014cited by this paper
Global-Scale Comparison of Passive (SMOS) and Active (ASCAT) Satellite Based Microwave Soil Moisture Retrievals with Soil Moisture Simulations (MERRA-Land)
2014cited by this paper
Validation and scale dependencies of the triangle method for the evaporative fraction estimation over heterogeneous areas
2014cited by this paper
Soil Moisture downscaling algorithm for combining radar and radiometer observations for SMAP mission
2014cited by this paper
A SAR Interferometric Model for Soil Moisture
2014cited by this paper
Remote monitoring of soil moisture using passive microwave-based techniques — Theoretical basis and overview of selected algorithms for AMSR-E
2014cited by this paper
odeling soil parameters using hyperspectral image reflectance in ubtropical coastal wetlands aveen
2014cited by this paper
Combining SMOS with visible and near/shortwave/thermal infrared satellite data for high resolution soil moisture estimates
2014cited by this paper
Dual-model approaches for evapotranspiration analyses over homo- and heterogeneous land surface conditions
2014cited by this paper
A Downscaling Approach for SMOS Land Observations: Evaluation of High-Resolution Soil Moisture Maps Over the Iberian Peninsula
2014cited by this paper
Evaluation of IEM, Dubois, and Oh Radar Backscatter Models Using Airborne L-Band SAR
2014cited by this paper
Multi-frequency analysis of soil moisture vertical heterogeneity effect on radar backscatter
2014cited by this paper
Similarities Between Spaceborne Active and Airborne Passive Microwave Observations at 1 km Resolution
2014cited by this paper
Sensitivity of multi-parameter soil moisture retrievals to incidence angle configuration
2014cited by this paper
The Chott El Djerid, Tunisia: Observation and Discussion of a SAR Phase Signature Over Evaporitic Soils
2014cited by this paper
A Simulation Study of Compact Polarimetry for Radar Retrieval of Soil Moisture
2014cited by this paper
Assessment of the relationship between thermal-infrared-based temperature−vegetation dryness index and microwave satellite-derived soil moisture
2014cited by this paper
Improvement of AMSR2 soil moisture algorithm with considering temperature profile effects in dry soil: A case study in Heihe basin
2014cited by this paper
An appraisal of soil moisture operational estimates accuracy from SMOS MIRAS using validated in-situ observations acquired at a Mediterranean environment.
2014cited by this paper
A modified perpendicular drought index in NIR-Red reflectance space
2014cited by this paper
A spatially coherent global soil moisture product with improved temporal resolution
2014cited by this paper
A novel approach to polarimetric SAR data processing based on Nonlinear PCA
2014cited by this paper
An appraisal of the accuracy of operational soil moisture estimates from SMOS MIRAS using validated in situ observations acquired in a Mediterranean environment
2014cited by this paper
Improved spatial resolution in soil moisture retrieval at arid mining area using apparent thermal inertia
2014cited by this paper
Estimating soil moisture and the relationship with crop yield using surface temperature and vegetation index
2014cited by this paper
Integration of Remotely Sensed Images and Electromagnetic Models into a Bayesian Approach for Soil Moisture Content Retrieval: Methodology and Effect of Prior Information
2014cited by this paper
A comparison of two models to predict soil moisture from remote sensing data of RADARSAT II
2014cited by this paper
‘Remote Sensing of Energy Fluxes and Soil Moisture Content’
2013cited by this paper
Errata: Mapping soil water content under sparse vegetation and changeable sky conditions: comparison of two thermal inertia approaches
2013cited by this paper
Relating satellite gravimetry data to global soil moisture products via data harmonization and correlation analysis
2013cited by this paper
Remote Sensing of Soil Moisture in Vineyards Using Airborne and Ground-Based Thermal Inertia Data
2013cited by this paper
Evaluation of polarimetric Radarsat-2 SAR data for development of soil moisture retrieval algorithms over a chronosequence of black spruce boreal forests
2013cited by this paper
"Earth observation for land-atmosphere interaction science", Preface
2013cited by this paper
A method of estimating soil moisture based on the linear decomposition of mixture pixels
2013cited by this paper
Coupling two radar backscattering models to assess soil roughness and surface water content at farm scale
2013cited by this paper
Inter-comparison of microwave satellite soil moisture retrievals over the Murrumbidgee Basin, southeast Australia
2013cited by this paper
Analysis of microwave polarization difference index characteristics about different vegetation types in northeast of China
2013cited by this paper
Soil moisture retrieving using hyperspectral data with the application of wavelet analysis
2013cited by this paper
First evaluation of SMOS L2 soil moisture products using in situ observation data of MAVEX on the Mongolian Plateau in 2010 and 2011
2013cited by this paper
Sensitivity study of soil moisture on the temporal evolution of surface temperature over bare surfaces
2013cited by this paper
Soil Moisture Estimation Under Low Vegetation Cover Using a Multi-Angular Polarimetric Decomposition
2013cited by this paper
Prediction of soil organic carbon for different levels of soil moisture using Vis-NIR spectroscopy
2013cited by this paper
Comparison between SAR Soil Moisture Estimates and Hydrological Model Simulations over the Scrivia Test Site
2013cited by this paper
Appraisal of SMOS soil moisture at a catchment scale in a temperate maritime climate
2013cited by this paper
Evaluation of Soil Moisture Retrieval from the ERS and Metop Scatterometers in the Lower Mekong Basin
2013cited by this paper
AMSR2 validation results
2013cited by this paper
Brightness Temperature and Soil Moisture Validation at Different Scales During the SMOS Validation Campaign in the Rur and Erft Catchments, Germany
2013cited by this paper
Estimation of soil moisture using optical/thermal infrared remote sensing in the Canadian Prairies
2013cited by this paper
Utilizing complementarity of active/passive microwave observations at L-band for soil moisture studies in sandy soils
2013cited by this paper
Soil moisture and biomass retrieval using ALOS/PALSAR data
2013cited by this paper
AMSR2 soil moisture validation in South Korea
2013cited by this paper
Spatial upscaling of in-situ soil moisture measurements based on MODIS-derived apparent thermal inertia
2013cited by this paper
Machine Learning Techniques for Downscaling SMOS Satellite Soil Moisture Using MODIS Land Surface Temperature for Hydrological Application
2013cited by this paper
A sensitivity analysis of the SimSphere SVAT model in the context of EO-based operational products development
2013cited by this paper
Critical analysis of thermal inertia approaches for surface soil water content retrieval
2013cited by this paper
Relation between Seasonally Detrended Shortwave Infrared Reflectance Data and Land Surface Moisture in Semi-Arid Sahel
2013cited by this paper
Detecting changes in surface soil moisture content using differential SAR interferometry
2013cited by this paper
Estimation of soil moisture from airborne hyperspectral imagery with support vector regression
2013cited by this paper
Spatial patterns of SMOS downscaled soil moisture maps over the remedhus network (Spain)
2012cited by this paper
A First Assessment of the SMOS Soil Moisture Product With In Situ and Modeled Data in Italy and Luxembourg
2012cited by this paper
A new approach for validating satellite estimates of soil moisture using large-scale precipitation: Comparing AMSR-E products
2012cited by this paper
Trend-preserving blending of passive and active microwave soil moisture retrievals
2012cited by this paper
SMOS RF Interference Scenario: Status and Actions Taken to Improve the RFI Environment in the 1400-1427 MHz Passive Band
2012cited by this paper
A downscaling approach to combine SMOS multi-angular and full-polarimetric observations with MODIS VIS/IR data into high resolution soil moisture maps
2012cited by this paper
Use of TerraSAR-X Data to Retrieve Soil Moisture Over Bare Soil Agricultural Fields
2012cited by this paper
A semi-empirical inversion model for assessing surface soil moisture using AMSR-E brightness temperatures
2012cited by this paper
Validation of SMOS Soil Moisture Products over the Maqu and Twente Regions
2012cited by this paper
SMOS calibration and validation over the Salar de Uyuni
2012cited by this paper
First Results of SMOS Soil Moisture Validation in the Upper Danube Catchment
2012cited by this paper
Sentinels for science: potential of Sentinel-1, -2, and -3 missions for scientific observations of ocean, cryosphere, and land
2012cited by this paper
Validation of Soil Moisture and Ocean Salinity (SMOS) Soil Moisture Over Watershed Networks in the U.S.
2012cited by this paper
Evaluation of SMOS Soil Moisture Products Over Continental U.S. Using the SCAN/SNOTEL Network
2012cited by this paper
Spatial variability and its scale dependency of observed and modeled soil moisture over different climate regions
2012cited by this paper
Downscaling SMOS-Derived Soil Moisture Using MODIS Visible/Infrared Data
2011cited by this paper
Laboratory Measurement of the DInSAR Response to Spatiotemporal Variations in Soil Moisture
2011cited by this paper
Soil moisture estimation through ASCAT and AMSR-E sensors: An intercomparison and validation study across Europe
2011cited by this paper
Estimating Surface Soil Moisture from TerraSAR-X Data over Two Small Catchments in the Sahelian Part of Western Niger
2011cited by this paper
A Proposed Extension to the Soil Moisture and Ocean Salinity Level 2 Algorithm for Mixed Forest and Moderate Vegetation Pixels
2011cited by this paper
Retrievals of turbulent heat fluxes and soil moisture content by Remote Sensing
2011cited by this paper
Denoising of Hyperspectral Imagery Using Principal Component Analysis and Wavelet Shrinkage
2011cited by this paper
A soil moisture and temperature network for SMOS validation in Western Denmark
2011cited by this paper
Earth observation for land-atmosphere interaction science
2011cited by this paper
ASCAT soil wetness index validation through in situ and modeled soil moisture data in central Italy
2010cited by this paper
Investigating soil moisture-climate interactions in a changing climate: A review
2010cited by this paper
The SMOS Mission: New Tool for Monitoring Key Elements ofthe Global Water Cycle
2010cited by this paper
MULTIPLE-MODEL BASED VERIFICATION OF JAPANESE ROAD DATA
2010cited by this paper
Mapping surface soil moisture over the Gourma mesoscale site (Mali) by using ENVISAT ASAR data
2010cited by this paper
Monitoring the effects of land use and cover type changes on soil moisture using remote-sensing data: A case study in China's Yongding River basin
2010cited by this paper
The Soil Moisture Active Passive (SMAP) Mission
2010cited by this paper
A combination of remote sensing data and topographic attributes for the spatial and temporal monitoring of soil wetness
2010cited by this paper

CITED BY

Soil moisture prediction research in the Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei region based on particle swarm optimized extreme learning machine
2026cites this paper
Spatiotemporal statistical evaluation of recent active and passive satellite-derived soil moisture products across Central Asia under multiple scenarios
2026cites this paper
A global framework for subsurface soil moisture estimation: Coupling fractal Richards equation with Bayesian optimization
2026cites this paper
Assessing the Impact of Polarization on Soil Moisture Retrieval Using C-band SAR Data Across Diverse Crop Structures
2026cites this paper
Harnessing satellite-driven insights for dynamic soil moisture tracking in smart farming systems
2026cites this paper
AI in soil moisture remote sensing
2026cites this paper
Evaluation of the WEPS hydrology sub-model for surface soil water content under different tillage practices in the inland Pacific Northwest, USA
2025cites this paper
A stand-alone framework for predicting spatiotemporal errors in satellite-based soil moisture using tree-based models and deep neural networks
2025cites this paper
Comparing UAV-Based Hyperspectral and Satellite-Based Multispectral Data for Soil Moisture Estimation Using Machine Learning
2025cites this paper
A data driven comparison of hybrid machine learning techniques for soil moisture modeling using remote sensing imagery
2025cites this paper
A compact and rugged hyperspectral camera for remote sensing in the thermal infrared based on Fourier transform spectrometry
2025cites this paper
Monitoring tropical soil moisture using remote sensing technology: A mini review
2025cites this paper
Soil Moisture Estimation Using Combined SAR and Optical Imagery: Application of Seasonal Machine Learning Algorithms
2025cites this paper
Contribution of ECOSTRESS thermal imagery to wetland mapping: Application to heathland ecosystems
2025cites this paper
Integration of Sentinel-1 and -2 imagery through advanced cloud computing improves hillside vineyard soil moisture analysis
2025cites this paper
Remotely Sensed High‐Resolution Soil Moisture and Evapotranspiration: Bridging the Gap Between Science and Society
2025cites this paper
Estimation of the Spatiotemporal Variability of Surface soil Moisture Using Machine Learning Methods Integrating Satellite and Ground-based Soil Moisture and Environmental Data
2025cites this paper
Advancing basin-scale drought monitoring: Development of a regional combined drought index using precipitation, soil moisture, and vegetation data
2025cites this paper
The passive microwave remote sensing in soil moisture retrieval: products, models, applications and challenges
2025cites this paper
Meter-level resolution surface soil moisture estimation over agricultural fields from time-series quad-pol SAR with constraints of coarse resolution CCI data products
2025cites this paper
Controls on spatial and temporal variability of soil moisture across a heterogeneous boreal forest landscape
2025cites this paper
RegreSSM: A novel software tool for downscaling the SMAP L3 soil moisture operational product utilizing the Ts/VI feature space and Sentinel-3 data
2025cites this paper
Soil Moisture Monitoring Method and Data Products: Current Research Status and Future Development Trends
2025cites this paper
Evaluation of Satellite-Based Global Navigation Satellite System Reflectometry (GNSS-R) Soil Moisture Products in Complex Terrain: A Case Study of the Yunnan–Guizhou Plateau
2025cites this paper
Soil Moisture Prediction Using Remote Sensing and Machine Learning Algorithms: A Review on Progress, Challenges, and Opportunities
2025influential citation
Soil Organic Carbon Mapping Using Multi-Frequency SAR Data and Machine Learning Algorithms
2025cites this paper
Coordinating high-resolution hyperspectral and RGB video acquisition of dynamic natural water scenes
2025cites this paper
Spatial Downscaling of SMAP Soil Moisture Product by Using Deep Belief Network
2025cites this paper
In-situ and triple collocation-based evaluations of Tianmu-1 global soil moisture products
2025cites this paper
Soil Moisture Retrieval from Soil Moisture Active Passive (SMAP) Satellite: A Validation and Error Analysis Using Ground-Based Observation Over Bangladesh
2025cites this paper
Coupling differentiable tau-omega model with Kolmogorov-Arnold network for soil moisture estimation over the Tibetan Plateau
2025cites this paper
A novel random forest approach to downscale SMAP soil moisture products to 100 m resolution using temporally closest satellite observation data
2025cites this paper
Evaluation and improvement of spatiotemporal estimation and transferability of multi-layer and profile soil moisture in the Qinghai Lake and Heihe River basins using multi-strategy constraints
2025cites this paper
From theory to hydrological practice: Leveraging CYGNSS data over seven years for advanced soil moisture monitoring
2025cites this paper
Soil moisture product consistency for operational drought monitoring in Europe
2025cites this paper
Drought Dynamics and Drivers Across Wheat Fields in the Huaihe Basin: Improved Temperature Vegetation Drought Index Using Reinforcement Learning
2025cites this paper
Soil moisture estimation with microwave remote sensing: a systematic review and meta-analysis
2025cites this paper
Improving Soil Moisture Estimation by Integrating Remote Sensing Data into HYDRUS-1D Using an Ensemble Kalman Filter Approach
2025cites this paper
Designing and field calibration of low-cost microcontroller-based soil moisture sensor for subsurface drip-irrigation system
2025cites this paper
A critical review on the applications of Sentinel satellite datasets for soil moisture assessment in crop production
2025cites this paper
Combined Measurement of Soil Permittivity and Electrical Conductivity Using UAV‐Based Ground Penetrating Radar
2025cites this paper
ESA CCI Soil Moisture GAPFILLED: an independent global gap-free satellite climate data record with uncertainty estimates
2025cites this paper
Automated Production of Medium Spatial Resolution Soil Moisture Remote Sensing Products Based on Google Earth Engine
2025cites this paper
Estimating soil moisture at farm scale with high spatial resolution: integrating remote sensing data, and machine learning
2025cites this paper
A novel soil moisture evaluation framework incorporating brightness temperature and a high-resolution 1 km summer brightness temperature dataset
2025cites this paper
A Review of Evapotranspiration Estimation Models: Advances and Future Development
2025cites this paper
Isotope data-constrained hydrological model improves soil moisture simulation and runoff source apportionment
2024cites this paper
Downscaling SMAP soil moisture product in cold and arid region: Incorporating NDSI and BSI into the random forest algorithm
2024cites this paper
Using the surface scattering mechanism from dual-pol SAR data to estimate topsoil particle-sizefractions
2024cites this paper
A Machine Learning-Based High-Resolution Soil Moisture Mapping and Spatial–Temporal Analysis: The mlhrsm Package
2024cites this paper
A systematic review on remote sensing of wetland environments
2024cites this paper
Multi-spectral surface emissivity as an indicator of soil water content and soil water content changes in arid soils
2024cites this paper
A Survey of Wireless Soil Sensing Technologies
2024cites this paper
Simulation-based inference for parameter estimation of complex watershed simulators
2024cites this paper
Soil moisture mapping from SMOS: evaluating the accuracy of the operational product in a Mediterranean setting
2024cites this paper
Calibration of the SMAP Soil Moisture Retrieval Algorithm to Reduce Bias Over the Amazon Rainforest
2024cites this paper
Temporal Stability of Grassland Soil Moisture Utilising Sentinel-2 Satellites and Sparse Ground-Based Sensor Networks
2024cites this paper
Evaluation and improvement of temporal robustness and transfer performance of surface soil moisture estimated by machine learning regression algorithms
2024cites this paper
Spatial and Temporal Variability of Soil Moisture and Its Driving Factors in the Northern Agricultural Regions of China
2024cites this paper
A novel validation of satellite soil moisture using SM2RAIN-derived rainfall estimates
2024cites this paper
Multi-Sensor Remote Sensing Data Integration for Agricultural Droughts: A PRISMA-Based Review in the Indian Context
2024cites this paper
Multi-Temporal Remote Sensing of Inland Surface Waters: A Fusion of Sentinel-1&2 Data Applied to Small Seasonal Ponds in Semiarid Environments
2024cites this paper
Dynamic monitoring of surface soil moisture fluctuations using synthetic aperture radar and data-driven algorithms
2024cites this paper
Spatial downscaling of SMAP soil moisture to high resolution using machine learning over China’s Loess Plateau
2024cites this paper
Evaluating the ability of the Wind Erosion Prediction System (WEPS) to simulate near-surface wind speeds in the Inland Pacific Northwest, USA
2024cites this paper
Assessment of Forest Cover Dynamics in Dedo District, Oromia Region, Ethiopia, Using Machine Learning Algorithm
2024cites this paper
Generalized spatio-temporal-spectral integrated fusion for soil moisture downscaling
2024cites this paper
Defining Brightness-Shape-Moisture Soil Parameters for Southern Africa From Hyperion Hyperspectral Imagery
2024cites this paper
Advances in Soil Moisture Retrieval From the Sentinel Products
2024cites this paper
Characterizing Satellite Soil Moisture Drydown: A Bivariate Filtering Approach
2024cites this paper
Advanced Technologies of Soil Moisture Monitoring in Precision Agriculture
2024cites this paper
Heavy Metal Concentration Estimation for Different Farmland Soils Based on Projection Pursuit and LightGBM with Hyperspectral Images
2024cites this paper
Bibliometric Analysis of Remote Sensing over Marine Areas for Sustainable Development: Global Trends and Worldwide Collaboration
2024cites this paper
An experiential account with recommendations for the design, installation, operation and maintenance of a farm-scale soil moisture sensing and mapping system
2024cites this paper
Ensembles of Multiple Models for Soil Moisture Retrieval from Remote Sensing Data over Agricultural Areas: A Deep Learning-based Framework
2024cites this paper
Evaluation of Satellite-Based Models for Surface Soil Moisture Estimation Using Sentinel-1 Data: A Case Study
2024cites this paper
The status of artificial wetland areas in light of climate change using Geospatial systems: Case study Ain Zada Lake (Algeria)
2024cites this paper
Estimation of Sentinel-1 derived soil moisture using modified Dubois model
2024influential citation
Retrieving Surface and Rootzone Soil Moisture Using Microwave Remote Sensing
2024cites this paper
Enhancing Global Surface Soil Moisture Estimation From ESA CCI and SMAP Product With a Conditional Variational Autoencoder
2024cites this paper
Comparative analysis of SAOCOM and Sentinel-1 data for surface soil moisture retrieval using a change detection method in a semiarid region (Douro River's basin, Spain)
2024cites this paper
A First Exploration of the Ts/VI “Analytical Triangle” Technique with UAV Imagery for Deriving Key Surface Energy Balance Parameters at Very High Spatial Resolution
2024cites this paper
Analyzing the Spatiotemporal Dynamics of Drought in Shaanxi Province
2024cites this paper
NISAR Time-Series Ratio Algorithm for Soil Moisture Retrieval: Prelaunch Evaluation With SMAPVEX12 Field Campaign Data
2024cites this paper
Seasonal forecast of soil moisture over Mediterranean-climate forest catchments using a Machine Learning approach
2023cites this paper
Deep Learning for Daily Spatiotemporally Continuity of Satellite Surface Soil Moisture over Eastern China in Summer
2023cites this paper
Application of sentinel-1 SAR-derived vegetation descriptors for soil moisture retrieval and plant height prediction during the wheat growth cycle
2023cites this paper
Comparative assessment of surface soil moisture simulations by the coupled wcm-iem vs. data-driven models using the Sentinel 1 and 2 satellite images
2023cites this paper
Surface soil moisture retrieval through combining LST-VI feature space with soil porosity
2023influential citation
ChinaCropSM1 km: a fine 1 km daily soil moisture dataset for dryland wheat and maize across China during 1993–2018
2023cites this paper
Spatial Downscaling and Gap-Filling of SMAP Soil Moisture to High Resolution Using MODIS Surface Variables and Machine Learning Approaches over ShanDian River Basin, China
2023cites this paper
Global Soil Moisture Estimation based on GPM IMERG Data using a Site Specific Adjusted Antecedent Precipitation Index
2023cites this paper
Surface Soil Moisture Estimation Using a Neural Network Model in Bare Land and Vegetated Areas
2023cites this paper
Examining the variation of soil moisture from cosmic-ray neutron probes footprint: experimental results from a COSMOS-UK site
2023cites this paper
Impact of the Variability of Vegetation, Soil Moisture, and Building Density between City Districts on Land Surface Temperature, Warsaw, Poland
2023cites this paper
Innovative data clustering method improves drought prediction in heterogeneous landscapes using GEE-derived remote sensing indices
2023cites this paper
Assessing and comparing the subseasonal variations of summer soil moisture of satellite products over eastern China
2023cites this paper
Exploiting satellite data for total direct runoff prediction using CN-based MSME model.
2023cites this paper
Soil moisture modeling over agricultural fields using C-band synthetic aperture radar and modified Dubois model
2023cites this paper
Spatial downscaling of satellite soil moisture products based on apparent thermal inertia: Considering the effect of vegetation condition
2023cites this paper