Defining and Estimating Intervention Effects for Groups that will Develop an Auxiliary Outcome

It has recently become popular to define treatment effects for subsets of the target population characterized by variables not observable at the time a treatment decision is made. Characterizing and estimating such treatment effects is tricky; the most popular but naive approach inappropriately adjusts for variables affected by treatment and so is biased. We consider several appropriate ways to formalize the effects: principal stratification, stratification on a single potential auxiliary variable, stratification on an observed auxiliary variable and stratification on expected levels of auxiliary variables. We then outline identifying assumptions for each type of estimand. We evaluate the utility of these estimands and estimation procedures for decision making and understanding causal processes, contrasting them with the concepts of direct and indirect effects. We motivate our development with examples from nephrology and cancer screening, and use simulated data and real data on cancer screening to illustrate the estimation methods.

• Publication year

  2006

• Venue

  Statistical Science

• Publication date

  2006-09-16

• Fields of study

  Mathematics, Economics

• Identifiers
  DOI 10.1214/088342306000000655arXiv math/0609457
• External record

  Open on Semantic Scholar

• Source metadata

  Semantic Scholar

• No claims are published for this paper.

• No concepts are published for this paper.

• Bounds on causal effects in three‐arm trials with non‐compliance

  2006cited by this paper
• The psychological impact of mammographic screening. A systematic review

  2005cited by this paper
• Causal Models for Randomized Physician Encouragement Trials in Treating Primary Care Depression

  2004influential reference
• A Structural Approach to Selection Bias

  2004cited by this paper
• Estimation of Direct and Indirect Causal Effects in Longitudinal Studies

  2004cited by this paper
• Estimation of treatment effects in randomised trials with non-compliance and a dichotomous outcome using structural mean models

  2004cited by this paper
• Direct and Indirect Causal Effects via Potential Outcomes *

  2004cited by this paper
• Quantifying Biases in Causal Models: Classical Confounding vs Collider-Stratification Bias

  2003cited by this paper
• Effect of dialysis dose and membrane flux in maintenance hemodialysis.

  2003cited by this paper
• The Statistical Analysis of Failure Time Data (2nd Ed.). John D. Kalbfleisch and Ross L. Prentice

  2003cited by this paper
• The Statistical Analysis of Failure Time Data

  2003cited by this paper
• Estimation of Causal Effects via Principal Stratification When Some Outcomes are Truncated by “Death”

  2003influential reference
• Causal inference with generalized structural mean models

  2003cited by this paper
• Sensitivity Analysis for the Assessment of Causal Vaccine Effects on Viral Load in HIV Vaccine Trials

  2003cited by this paper
• The compliance score as a regressor in randomized trials.

  2003cited by this paper
• Weighting in instrumental variables and G‐estimation

  2003cited by this paper
• The Chronic Renal Insufficiency Cohort (CRIC) Study: Design and Methods.

  2003cited by this paper
• Principal Stratification in Causal Inference

  2002influential reference
• Benefits, harms and costs of screening mammography in women 70 years and over: a systematic review

  2002cited by this paper
• Covariance Adjustment in Randomized Experiments and Observational Studies

  2002cited by this paper
• Effects of increased peritoneal clearances on mortality rates in peritoneal dialysis: ADEMEX, a prospective, randomized, controlled trial.

  2002cited by this paper
• Differential effects of high‐quality child care

  2002cited by this paper
• Administrative and artificial censoring in censored regression models

  2001influential reference
• Direct and Indirect Effects

  2001cited by this paper
• Using information on realized effects to determine prospective causal effects

  2001cited by this paper
• THE EFFECTS OF NORMAL AS COMPARED WITH LOW HEMATOCRIT VALUES IN PATIENTS WITH CARDIAC DISEASE WHO ARE RECEIVING HEMODIALYSIS AND EPOETIN

  2000cited by this paper
• Sensitivity Analysis for Selection bias and unmeasured Confounding in missing Data and Causal inference models

  2000cited by this paper
• Clinical trials comparing two treatment policies: which aspects of the treatment policies make a difference?

  1998cited by this paper
• Bounds on Treatment Effects from Studies with Imperfect Compliance

  1997cited by this paper
• Bayesian inference for causal effects in randomized experiments with noncompliance

  1997cited by this paper
• Identification of Causal effects Using Instrumental Variables

  1996cited by this paper
• Identification of Causal Effects Using Instrumental Variables: Comment

  1996cited by this paper
• Modeling the Drop-Out Mechanism in Repeated-Measures Studies

  1995cited by this paper
• The paired availability design: a proposal for evaluating epidural analgesia during labor.

  1994cited by this paper
• Adjusting for differential rates of prophylaxis therapy for PCP in high- versus low-dose AZT treatment arms in an AIDS randomized trial

  1994cited by this paper
• Correcting for non-compliance in randomized trials using structural nested mean models

  1994cited by this paper
• Estimating the causal effect of smoking cessation in the presence of confounding factors using a rank preserving structural failure time model.

  1993cited by this paper
• A method for the analysis of randomized trials with compliance information: an application to the Multiple Risk Factor Intervention Trial.

  1993cited by this paper
• Identifiability and Exchangeability for Direct and Indirect Effects

  1992influential reference
• G-Estimation of the Effect of Prophylaxis Therapy for Pneumocystis carinii Pneumonia on the Survival of AIDS Patients

  1992influential reference
• Estimation of the time-dependent accelerated failure time model in the presence of confounding factors

  1992cited by this paper
• Effect modification and the limits of biological inference from epidemiologic data.

  1991cited by this paper
• On estimating efficacy from clinical trials.

  1991cited by this paper
• Compliance as an Explanatory Variable in Clinical Trials

  1991cited by this paper
• [On the Application of Probability Theory to Agricultural Experiments. Essay on Principles. Section 9.] Comment: Neyman (1923) and Causal Inference in Experiments and Observational Studies

  1990cited by this paper
• On the Application of Probability Theory to Agricultural Experiments. Essay on Principles. Section 9

  1990cited by this paper
• Nonparametric Bounds on Treatment Effects

  1989cited by this paper
• Periodic Screening for Breast Cancer: The Health Insurance Plan Project and its Sequelae, 1963–1986

  1989cited by this paper
• A new approach to causal inference in mortality studies with a sustained exposure period—application to control of the healthy worker survivor effect

  1986cited by this paper
• Identifiability, exchangeability, and epidemiological confounding.

  1986cited by this paper
• The Consequences of Adjustment for a Concomitant Variable that Has Been Affected by the Treatment

  1984cited by this paper
• Econometric Issues in the Analysis of Regressions with Generated Regressors.

  1984cited by this paper
• The central role of the propensity score in observational studies for causal effects

  1983influential reference
• The Statistical Analysis of Failure Time Data

  1980cited by this paper
• Bayesian Inference for Causal Effects: The Role of Randomization

  1978cited by this paper
• Estimating causal effects of treatments in randomized and nonrandomized studies.

  1974cited by this paper
• On the Identifiability of Finite Mixtures

  1968cited by this paper
• Causality : Models , Reasoning , and Inference

  year unknowncited by this paper

• Causal mediation analysis for difference-in-difference design and panel data

  2025cites this paper
• Estimating the Local Average Treatment Effect Without the Exclusion Restriction

  2025cites this paper
• Causal Inference Over a Subpopulation: The Effect of Malaria Vaccine in Women During Pregnancy

  2024cites this paper
• We Need Subject Matter Expertise to Choose and Identify Causal Estimands: Comment on “Estimands for Recurrent Event Endpoints in the Presence of a Terminal Event”

  2023cites this paper
• Principal stratification with continuous post-treatment variables: nonparametric identification and semiparametric estimation

  2023cites this paper
• Nonparametric estimation of mediation effects with a general treatment

  2022cites this paper
• Efficient, doubly robust estimation of the effect of dose switching for switchers in a randomized clinical trial

  2021cites this paper
• Assessing the Commonly Used Assumptions in Estimating the Principal Causal Effect in Clinical Trials

  2021cites this paper
• Translating questions to estimands in randomized clinical trials with intercurrent events

  2021cites this paper
• Statistical methods for mediation analysis in the era of high-throughput genomics: Current successes and future challenges

  2021cites this paper
• Identification of Causal Effects Within Principal Strata Using Auxiliary Variables

  2020cites this paper
• Principal stratum strategy: Potential role in drug development

  2020cites this paper
• Causal Inference Methodology for Comparisons of Hospital Quality of Care

  2019cites this paper
• Latent Class Dynamic Mediation Model with Application to Smoking Cessation Data

  2019cites this paper
• Causal Inference with Intermediates :

  2018cites this paper
• Discovering treatment effect heterogeneity through post‐treatment variables with application to the effect of class size on mathematics scores

  2018cites this paper
• Principal stratification : applications and extensions in clinical trials with intermediate variables

  2017cites this paper
• Principal Score Methods: Assumptions, Extensions, and Practical Considerations

  2017cites this paper
• The Long-Run Impact of Childhood Poverty and the Mediating Role of Education

  2017cites this paper
• Employed Women and Marital Union Stability: It Helps When Men Help

  2017cites this paper
• Misclassified exposure in epigenetic mediation analyses. Does DNA methylation mediate effects of smoking on birthweight?

  2017cites this paper
• simcausal R Package: Conducting Transparent and Reproducible Simulation Studies of Causal Effect Estimation with Complex Longitudinal Data.

  2017cites this paper
• simcausal Package : Technical Details and Extended Examples of Simulations with Complex Longitudinal Data

  2017cites this paper
• Performance of principal scores to estimate the marginal compliers causal effect of an intervention

  2016cites this paper
• Explaining Causal Findings Without Bias: Detecting and Assessing Direct Effects

  2016cites this paper
• Intergenerational poverty transmission in Europe: The role of education

  2016cites this paper
• Compared to what? Variation in the impacts of early childhood education by alternative care type

  2016cites this paper
• Generalized Structural Mean Models for Evaluating Depression as a Post-treatment Effect Modifier of a Jobs Training Intervention

  2016influential citation
• EFFICIENT NONPARAMETRIC ESTIMATION OF CAUSAL MEDIATION EFFECTS

  2016cites this paper
• Principal Score Methods: Assumptions and Extensions

  2016cites this paper
• Principal stratification analysis using principal scores

  2016cites this paper
• 6. Moderated treatment effects

  2016cites this paper
• Semi-Parametric Estimation in Network Data and Tools for Conducting Complex Simulation Studies in Causal Inference

  2016cites this paper
• Generalized Structural Mean Models for Evaluating Depression as a Post-treatment Effect Modifier of a Jobs Training Intervention

  2016cites this paper
• Causal Effects in Mediation Modeling: An Introduction With Applications to Latent Variables

  2015cites this paper
• Assessing the sensitivity of methods for estimating principal causal effects

  2015cites this paper
• Joint modeling of survival and longitudinal data measured with error, with application to assessing immune correlates of protection in vaccine efficacy trials

  2015cites this paper
• Predicting Principal Stratum Membership in Randomized Environmental Interventions

  2015influential citation
• Bayesian sequential monitoring design for two‐arm randomized clinical trials with noncompliance

  2015cites this paper
• Tom Ten Have's contributions to causal inference and biostatistics: review and future research directions

  2014cites this paper
• Woman's employment makes unions more stable, if the partner contributes to the unpaid work

  2014cites this paper
• Mediation analysis when a continuous mediator is measured with error and the outcome follows a generalized linear model

  2014cites this paper
• Interpretation and identification of causal mediation.

  2014cites this paper
• Structural nested models and G-estimation: the partially realized promise

  2014cites this paper
• Women’s employment makes unions more stable, if the male partners contribute to the unpaid household work

  2014cites this paper
• Statistical Methods for Causal Mediation Analysis

  2013cites this paper
• Mediation analysis allowing for exposure-mediator interactions and causal interpretation: theoretical assumptions and implementation with SAS and SPSS macros.

  2013cites this paper
• The Balanced Survivor Average Causal Effect

  2013cites this paper
• New Perspectives on Causal Mediation Analysis

  2013cites this paper
• Causal Inference with Intermediates: Simple Methods for Principal Strata Effects and Natural Direct Effects

  2013cites this paper
• Conditioning on intermediates in perinatal epidemiology.

  2012cites this paper
• Causality, mediation and time: a dynamic viewpoint

  2012influential citation
• Armitage lecture 2010: Understanding treatment effects: the value of integrating longitudinal data and survival analysis

  2012cites this paper
• A review of causal estimation of effects in mediation analyses

  2012cites this paper
• The Causal Mediation Formula—A Guide to the Assessment of Pathways and Mechanisms

  2012cites this paper
• The prevention and treatment of missing data in clinical trials.

  2012cites this paper
• Sensitivity Analyses Comparing Time‐to‐Event Outcomes Only Existing in a Subset Selected Postrandomization and Relaxing Monotonicity

  2011cites this paper
• A method to estimate treatment efficacy among latent subgroups of a randomized clinical trial

  2011cites this paper
• The Mediation Formula: A Guide to the Assessment of Causal Pathways in Nonlinear Models

  2011cites this paper
• THE POTENTIAL FOR BIAS IN PRINCIPAL CAUSAL EFFECT ESTIMATION WHEN TREATMENT RECEIVED DEPENDS ON A KEY COVARIATE.

  2011cites this paper
• The Use of Propensity Scores in Mediation Analysis

  2011cites this paper
• Causal assessment of surrogacy in a meta-analysis of colorectal cancer trials.

  2011influential citation
• The Causal Mediation Formula – A practitioner guide to the assessment of causal pathways

  2011cites this paper
• Principal Stratification and Attribution Prohibition: Good Ideas Taken Too Far

  2011cites this paper
• Causal Inference in Randomized Trials with Noncompliance

  2011cites this paper
• The International Journal of Biostatistics Principal Stratification — a Goal or a Tool ?

  2011cites this paper
• Augmented designs to assess principal strata direct effects

  2011cites this paper
• Structural Nested Mean Models for Assessing Time‐Varying Effect Moderation

  2010cites this paper
• Bias Formulas for Sensitivity Analysis for Direct and Indirect Effects

  2010cites this paper
• Longitudinal Data with Follow-up Truncated by Death: Match the Analysis Method to Research Aims.

  2010cites this paper
• Direct and Indirect Effects for Neighborhood-Based Clustered and Longitudinal Data

  2010cites this paper
• A tutorial on principal stratification-based sensitivity analysis: application to smoking cessation studies

  2010cites this paper
• Mediation and moderation of treatment effects in randomised controlled trials of complex interventions

  2010cites this paper
• Semiparametric estimation of the average causal effect of treatment on an outcome measured after a postrandomization event, with missing outcome data.

  2010cites this paper
• The Prevention and Treatment of Missing Data in Clinical Trials. Pannel on Handling Missing Data in Clinical Trials

  2010cites this paper
• Estimation of controlled direct effects on a dichotomous outcome using logistic structural direct effect models

  2010cites this paper
• The Monotone Instrumental Variable in Randomized Trials with Noncompliance

  2010cites this paper
• Controlled Direct and Mediated Effects: Definition, Identification and Bounds

  2010cites this paper
• Identification, Inference and Sensitivity Analysis for Causal Mediation Effects

  2010cites this paper
• Nonparametric Partial Identi cation of Causal Net and Mechanism Average Treatment E ¤ ects

  2010cites this paper
• Odds ratios for mediation analysis for a dichotomous outcome.

  2010cites this paper
• Related Causal Frameworks for Surrogate Outcomes

  2009cites this paper
• Conceptual issues concerning mediation, interventions and composition

  2009cites this paper
• On the use of propensity scores in principal causal effect estimation

  2009cites this paper
• On the Distinction Between Interaction and Effect Modification

  2009cites this paper
• Correcting Instrumental Variables Estimators for Systematic Measurement Error.

  2009cites this paper
• Mediation and mechanism

  2009cites this paper
• Using latent outcome trajectory classes in causal inference.

  2009cites this paper
• Extended Instrumental Variables Estimation for Overall Effects

  2008cites this paper
• A Randomized Controlled Trial of a Close Monitoring Program for Minor Depression and Distress

  2008cites this paper
• Causal mediation analyses for randomized trials

  2008cites this paper
• Simple relations between principal stratification and direct and indirect effects

  2008cites this paper
• Causal Mediation Analyses with Rank Preserving Models

  2007cites this paper
• Statistical Methods in Medical Research Interventions Mediation and Moderation of Treatment Effects in Randomised Controlled Trials of Complex Mediation and Moderation of Treatment Effects in Randomised Controlled Trials of Complex Interventions

  year unknowncites this paper