Wolf in sheep's clothing: Model misspecification undermines tests of the neutral theory for life histories

Abstract Understanding the processes behind change in reproductive state along life‐history trajectories is a salient research program in evolutionary ecology. Two processes, state dependence and heterogeneity, can drive the dynamics of change among states. Both processes can operate simultaneously, begging the difficult question of how to tease them apart in practice. The Neutral Theory for Life Histories (NTLH) holds that the bulk of variations in life‐history trajectories is due to state dependence and is hence neutral: Once previous (breeding) state is taken into account, variations are mostly random. Lifetime reproductive success (LRS), the number of descendants produced over an individual's reproductive life span, has been used to infer support for NTLH in natura. Support stemmed from accurate prediction of the population‐level distribution of LRS with parameters estimated from a state dependence model. We show with Monte Carlo simulations that the current reliance of NTLH on LRS prediction in a null hypothesis framework easily leads to selecting a misspecified model, biased estimates and flawed inferences. Support for the NTLH can be spurious because of a systematic positive bias in estimated state dependence when heterogeneity is present in the data but ignored in the analysis. This bias can lead to spurious positive covariance between fitness components when there is in fact an underlying trade‐off. Furthermore, neutrality implied by NTLH needs a clarification because of a probable disjunction between its common understanding by evolutionary ecologists and its translation into statistical models of life‐history trajectories. Irrespective of what neutrality entails, testing hypotheses about the dynamics of change among states in life histories requires a multimodel framework because state dependence and heterogeneity can easily be mistaken for each other.

• Publication year

  2017

• Venue

  Ecology and Evolution

• Publication date

  2017-04-04

• Fields of study

  Biology, Medicine, Computer Science, Environmental Science

• Identifiers
  DOI 10.1002/ece3.2874PMID 28515871PMCID 5433986
• External record

  Open on Semantic Scholar

• Source metadata

  Semantic Scholar, PubMed

• No claims are published for this paper.

• No concepts are published for this paper.

• Wolf in sheep's clothing: Model misspecification undermines tests of the neutral theory for life histories

  2017cited by this paper
• Variation in the age of first reproduction: different strategies or individual quality?

  2016cited by this paper
• What is information?†

  2016cited by this paper
• The Conundrum of Heterogeneities in Life History Studies.

  2016influential reference
• From the Neutral Theory to a Comprehensive and Multiscale Theory of Ecological Equivalence

  2016cited by this paper
• Successful by Chance? The Power of Mixed Models and Neutral Simulations for the Detection of Individual Fixed Heterogeneity in Fitness Components

  2016influential reference
• Invisible Trade-offs: Van Noordwijk and de Jong and Life-History Evolution

  2016cited by this paper
• Life span and reproductive cost explain interspecific variation in the optimal onset of reproduction

  2016cited by this paper
• Extreme climate events and individual heterogeneity shape life‐history traits and population dynamics

  2015cited by this paper
• Linear Mixed-Effects Models using 'Eigen' and S4

  2015cited by this paper
• Use of posterior predictive checks as an inferential tool for investigating individual heterogeneity in animal population vital rates

  2014cited by this paper
• The Shortlist Method for Fast Computation of the Earth Mover's Distance and Finding Optimal Solutions to Transportation Problems

  2014cited by this paper
• R: A language and environment for statistical computing.

  2014cited by this paper
• An evolutionary perspective on reproductive individual heterogeneity in a marine vertebrate.

  2014cited by this paper
• Life-history strategies of North American elk: trade-offs associated with reproduction and survival

  2013cited by this paper
• Looking for a needle in a haystack: inference about individual fitness components in a heterogeneous population

  2013influential reference
• Understanding predictive information criteria for Bayesian models

  2013cited by this paper
• Individual heterogeneity in reproductive rates and cost of reproduction in a long-lived vertebrate

  2013cited by this paper
• Neutral theory for life histories and individual variability in fitness components

  2012influential reference
• Selection for increased body length in Subantarctic fur seals on Amsterdam Island

  2011cited by this paper
• Individual quality: tautology or biological reality?

  2011cited by this paper
• Universal Ecological Patterns in College Basketball Communities

  2011cited by this paper
• Mechanisms of Life History Evolution: The Genetics and Physiology of Life History Traits and Trade-Offs

  2011cited by this paper
• The dynamic properties of individual-level party identification in the United States

  2011cited by this paper
• Static and dynamic expression of life history traits in the Northern Fulmar (Fulmarus glacialis).

  2011cited by this paper
• What is individual quality? An evolutionary perspective.

  2010cited by this paper
• Dynamic heterogeneity and life history variability in the kittiwake.

  2010influential reference
• Logistic Regression: Why We Cannot Do What We Think We Can Do, and What We Can Do About It

  2010cited by this paper
• Stage, age and individual stochasticity in demography

  2009influential reference
• Bayesian Inference: With Ecological Applications

  2009influential reference
• A simple method for distinguishing within- versus between-subject effects using mixed models

  2009cited by this paper
• Generalized linear mixed models: a practical guide for ecology and evolution.

  2009cited by this paper
• Dynamic heterogeneity in life histories.

  2009influential reference
• Using cross-classified multivariate mixed response models with application to life history traits in great tits (Parus major)

  2007cited by this paper
• Neutral theory: a historical perspective

  2007cited by this paper
• Why evolutionary biologists should be demographers.

  2007cited by this paper
• Making Sense of Evolution: The Conceptual Foundations of Evolutionary Biology

  2006cited by this paper
• Breeding performance, mate fidelity, and nest site fidelity in a long-lived seabird: behaving against the current?

  2006cited by this paper
• Joint modelling of breeding and survival in the kittiwake using frailty models

  2005cited by this paper
• Understanding AIC and BIC in Model Selection

  2004cited by this paper
• Multimodel Inference

  2004cited by this paper
• THE EVOLUTION OF TRADE‐OFFS: TESTING PREDICTIONS ON RESPONSE TO SELECTION AND ENVIRONMENTAL VARIATION

  2002cited by this paper
• Evaluation of some random effects methodology applicable to bird ringing data

  2002cited by this paper
• THE EVOLUTION OF TRADE-OFFS: TESTING PREDICTIONS ON RESPONSE TO SELECTION AND ENVIRONMENTAL VARIATION

  2002influential reference
• Individual Covariation in Life‐History Traits: Seeing the Trees Despite the Forest

  2002cited by this paper
• Comparing Classical Community Models: Theoretical Consequences for Patterns of Diversity

  2002cited by this paper
• Evolutionary Ecology: Concepts and Case Studies

  2001cited by this paper
• On the effect of the number of quadrature points in a logistic random effects model: an example

  2001cited by this paper
• Type S error rates for classical and Bayesian single and multiple comparison procedures

  2000cited by this paper
• The fall and rise of Dr Pangloss: adaptationism and the Spandrels paper 20 years later.

  2000cited by this paper
• Big houses, big cars, superfleas and the costs of reproduction.

  2000cited by this paper
• Unemployment persistence

  1998cited by this paper
• Frailty Models in Survival Analysis

  1996cited by this paper
• Estimating breeding proportions and testing hypotheses about costs of reproduction with capture-recapture data

  1994cited by this paper
• Winter host component reduces colonization by bird-cherry-oat aphid,Rhopalosiphum padi (L.) (homoptera, aphididae), and other aphids in cereal fields

  1994cited by this paper
• Analysis of Panel Data

  1989cited by this paper
• Acquisition and Allocation of Resources: Their Influence on Variation in Life History Tactics

  1986cited by this paper
• The spandrels of San Marco and the Panglossian paradigm: a critique of the adaptationist programme

  1979cited by this paper
• The Method of Multiple Working Hypotheses: With this method the dangers of parental affection for a favorite theory can be circumvented.

  1965cited by this paper
• The study of population growth in organisms grouped by stages

  1965cited by this paper
• The Method of Multiple Working Hypotheses

  1931cited by this paper
• Author's Personal Copy Theoretical Population Biology Modeling Reproductive Trajectories of Roe Deer Females: Fixed or Dynamic Heterogeneity?

  year unknowncited by this paper

• Trap‐dependence in capture–recapture studies: empirical evidence in vertebrates and biological meaning

  2025cites this paper
• Independence in Integrated Population Models

  2024cites this paper
• Maternal survival costs in an asocial mammal

  2022cites this paper
• Quantifying fixed individual heterogeneity in demographic parameters: Performance of correlated random effects for Bernoulli variables

  2021cites this paper
• Estimating Cetacean Bycatch From Non-representative Samples (I): A Simulation Study With Regularized Multilevel Regression and Post-stratification

  2021cites this paper
• Demystifying individual heterogeneity.

  2021influential citation
• Time and Chance: Using Age Partitioning to Understand How Luck Drives Variation in Reproductive Success

  2020cites this paper
• Variance as a life history outcome: Sensitivity analysis of the contributions of stochasticity and heterogeneity

  2020cites this paper
• Relative contributions of fixed and dynamic heterogeneity to variation in lifetime reproductive success in kestrels ( Falco tinnunculus )

  2020cites this paper
• When the going gets tough, the tough get going: Effect of extreme climate on an Antarctic seabird's life history

  2019cites this paper
• Estimation of Genetic Variance in Fitness, and Inference of Adaptation, When Fitness Follows a Log-Normal Distribution.

  2019cites this paper
• Individual heterogeneity in life‐history trade‐offs with age at first reproduction in capital breeding elephant seals

  2019cites this paper
• Individual heterogeneity and capture–recapture models: what, why and how?

  2018cites this paper
• General conclusion to the special issue Moving forward on individual heterogeneity

  2018cites this paper
• Variation in the vital rates of an Antarctic marine predator: the role of individual heterogeneity.

  2018influential citation
• Fitness consequences of peak reproductive effort in a resource pulse system

  2017cites this paper
• Individual heterogeneity and capture-recapture models: what, why and how?

  2017cites this paper
• Environmental correlates of reproduction, patterns of maternal allocation, and variation in adult female vital rates in the Weddell seal

  2017cites this paper
• Wolf in sheep's clothing: Model misspecification undermines tests of the neutral theory for life histories

  2017cites this paper
• From early life to senescence: individual heterogeneity in a long‐lived seabird

  2017cites this paper
• UvA-DARE (Digital Academic Repository) When the going gets tough, the tough get going: Effect of extreme climate on an Antarctic seabird's life history

  year unknowncites this paper